Foraging seals enable scientists to measure fish abundance across the vast Pacific Ocean

Mike Peña, UC Santa Cruz

Over the past 60 years, marine biologists at UC Santa Cruz have monitored the behavior of northern elephant seals that journey to nearby Año Nuevo Natural Reserve. With the seals gathering on the beach by the thousands to breed and molt, generations of researchers have been able to amass more than 350,000 observations on over 50,000 seals.

With the help of powerful technologies and the intrepidness to get close enough to carefully tag, weigh, and observe these loud and lumbering marine mammals, the long-term research project has extensive historical and real-time data on their fitness, foraging success, at-sea behavior, and population dynamics.

Roxanne Beltran is next in line to lead the project, and her new study being published on February 14 as the cover story in Science reports that seals can essentially act as “smart sensors” for monitoring fish populations in the ocean’s eerily dim “twilight zone” of water between 200 and 1,000 meters below sea level, where sunlight penetration all but stops, and today’s ocean monitoring tools cannot reach with ease. Ships and floating buoys only allow measurements of a tiny fraction of the ocean, while satellites can’t measure below the surface where fish occur.

Importantly, this zone holds the majority of the planet’s fish biomass. Because this is also where the seals feed, seals whose foraging success is tracked can provide a previously impossible way to measure the availability of fish populations across a vast ocean. This, Beltran said, represents a significant discovery because humans are considering harvesting these fish populations to satisfy humanity’s ever-increasing need for protein-rich foods.

“Given the importance of the ocean for carbon sequestration, climate regulation, oxygen production, and food for billions of people, there is an urgent need to measure changes in marine ecosystems, “Our research shows that the vast foraging extent and millions of feeding attempts by elephant seals make them a fantastic ecosystem sentinel, both for fish populations and top predators in the open ocean.”

For context, each seal makes an average of about 75,000 foraging attempts during a seven-month, roughly 6,000-mile journey across the Pacific Ocean. This means that tracking just 14 seals per year could provide estimates of fish availability across 4.4 million cubic kilometers of ocean volume.

Beyond that, weighing the seals also allows researchers to measure long-term fluctuations in prey abundance. And as commercial fleets increase the depth and breadth of their harvesting to satisfy demand, sustainable fisheries management requires assessing the size of fish populations and how they respond to environmental change.

Empowering students through publications

Besides the promise of providing visibility into the ocean’s mysterious mesopelagic zone, this study also stands out for another reason: The paper is co-authored by 14 undergraduates who took an immersive, inquiry-based field course taught by Beltran and Año Nuevo Reserve Director Patrick Robinson in which the students undertook projects analyzing the six decades of data from the seal research program. In the course, which continues to be offered at UC Santa Cruz, students participate in fieldwork, learn to generate scientific questions, perform exploratory data analyses, and present their results through mentored practice.

“We want the students to feel like they are part of a community of scientists, ” said Allison Payne, a graduate student in the Beltran Lab who served as the course’s teaching assistant. “It’s an incredible opportunity for the students and instructors alike to collaborate on real-world science, and it builds students’ confidence in navigating the scientific process. ”

Payne recently led the publication of another research article with student co-authors from a different offering of the field course, in this case, examining how the reproductive success of elephant seals diminishes after seals reach prime age.

At the outset of the course in 2022, students brainstormed research topics and chose to study how cohorts of seals fared in different years. Each pair of students tackled a subset of the project. One undergraduate student, Madi Reed, downloaded oceanographic data to test hypotheses about links between oceanographic conditions and the likelihood that seal pups would live long enough to produce pups of their own.

Reed (Rachel Carson ‘22, marine biology) discovered dramatic fluctuations in elephant seal survival and reproductive success over the last four decades strongly linked to ocean conditions where they forage. our classes could be applied to real research, ” she said. current drive to pursue a career in biological oceanographic research, where I hope to continue making useful data connections.”

Beltran Lab members also recently led a related viewpoint in Ecology Letters on the potential for long-term studies to provide these inclusive opportunities for training ecologists.

Sustaining the twilight zone

Fish in the twilight zone are ecologically important prey for economically important species, Beltran says, adding that the realm they inhabit may soon become a fishery. But little is known about twilight-zone fish: Scientists’ best estimates of their abundance spans a 10-fold range of uncertainty. Reductions in these fish populations could have huge impacts on many other species in the ecosystem, including species that humans rely on for sustenance and livestock feed.

This study integrated and applied research data obtained over the last six decades, including those by co-authors Burney LeBoeuf and Dan Costa, the two program leaders that preceded Beltran. “This effort documented the coupling between the elephant seals’ behavior thousands of miles at sea, to their breeding success on the beach, ” said Costa, distinguished professor of ecology and evolutionary biology. “This could only be accomplished with a long-time series coupled with a multidisciplinary team, including oceanographers, demographers, modelers, and seal biologists. ”

Previous discoveries born from this ongoing research included the long-distance foraging migrations of elephant seals, the high frequency of elephant seal foraging attempts for small fish, and the likely possibility that seal pup quality is linked to ocean health through maternal foraging success. The new study showed that the foraging success of elephant seals was tightly linked to a broad-scale oceanographic index that can be measured by orbiting satellites. “This linkage allowed us to measure the ocean’s pulse and estimate fluctuations in fish availability five decades into the past and a few years into the future, ” Beltran said. Hence, insights and tools from this study provide a critical ecological baseline for sustainable fishing and assess the impacts of anthropogenic environmental changes on fish populations at the scale of entire ocean basins.

In addition to Beltran, Payne, Reed, LeBoeuf, and Costa, the co-authors include Marm Kilpatrick, Conner Hale, Joffrey Jouma’a, Patrick Robinson, Emma Houle, Wade Matern, Alea Sabah, Kathryn Lewis, Samantha Sebandal, Allison Coughlin, Natalia Valdes Heredia, Francesca Penny, Sophie Rose Dalrymple, Heather Penny, Meghan Sherrier, Ben Peterson, and Joanne Reiter at UC Santa Cruz, and Elliott Hazen and Steven Bograd at NOAA.

Año Nuevo Natural Reserve is part of UC Nature, a network of more than 40 ecosystems across California managed for research, university-level teaching, and public use. UC Nature is the world’s largest university-operated system of natural reserves; no other
network of field sites can match its size, scope, and ecological diversity.

This research was supported by many funders, including the National Science Foundation, Office of Naval Research, Arnold and Mabel Beckman Foundation, and David and Lucile Packard Foundation.